From an initial observation, I think most people would say art and accounting are opposites. Think about what accounting programs teach students: to follow the rules; to conform to the guidelines; to count the costs and benefits of a decision; to use proper form; to be practical; and not to think abstractly. This makes sense because accounting is all about communicating the financial position of a business to interested parties, and the users of this accounting information want reliable and comparable data.
Now think about what art schools teach students. While an art instructor may teach students some principles of good form and design, the student is encouraged to think creatively, to create something unique, to express themselves, to create beauty, and to take risks.
So how did I come up with the statement, “The Artist and the New Accountant”? I believe there are many similarities between art and accounting. They both aim to communicate, express, and expose ideas, thoughts, and positions. Artists are communicators and so are accountants.
However, the accountant is like a factory worker. Their work is “planned, controlled, and measured.” An accountant can count on a fairly stable routine of processing data, operating software, and wooing clients. Accountants are like machines trying to complete tasks faster, cheaper, and better, and in some aspects, computers can perform the same tasks as an accountant. The result of this is that accountants are easily replaceable; there are several other accountants that are trained to do the same thing the same way.
But the artist on the other hand is dependent on his or her own talent and genius. The true artist is someone who creates something unique, fresh, and new. The true artist’s work cannot be “planned, controlled, and measured,” and there’s no limit to the type, style, beauty, or emotion of art.
If accountants started to think more like artists by trying to tell a story through their work, I think the accountant would be providing users with higher quality information. Instead of checking items off a list, what if an accountant thought, “What items do I need to include to tell the financial story of this company?” Instead of working on another spreadsheet, the accountant could think, “How can I organize this information in order to improve decision making?” I’ve included a couple quotes and edited them to apply in this context:
“Good art (accounting) tells the truth in the dark places. My experience also taught me that good art (accounting) is never about propaganda or proving a point. No, good art (accounting) is about telling great stories and great stories are what transform the world.”
“As businesses develop, it is the artists (accountants) who articulate the necessary financial information that embody our experience in business and provide parameters for ethics and values. Every so often the old accounting measurements lose their value because they become too small and confined to contain the complexities of the ever-transforming and expanding societies. In that moment new artists (accountants) are needed to encompass who we are becoming.”
I’m still working through theses idea, but I think there is some value in them. What are your thoughts?